
A PLANNED FAILED STATE
By: Raúl Zibechi

Banner by Adherents to the EZLN’s Sixth Declaration demanding that the 43 disappeared Ayotzinapa students be returned alive!
The State has been converted into a criminal institution criminal where the narco and politicians fuse to control society. A failed State that has been constructed in the last two decades to avoid the greatest nightmare of the elites: a second Mexican Revolution.
“Alive they were taken, alive we want them,” cries out María Ester Contreras, while twenty raised fists chant the slogan over the lane of the Latin American University of Puebla, upon receiving the Tata Vasco prize in the name of the collective Forces United for Our Disappeared in Mexico (Fuerzas Unidas por Nuestros Desaparecidos en México, Fundem), for its work against forced disappearances. The scene is overwhelming, since the family members, almost all mothers or sisters, cannot contain the crying and tears each time they speak in public at the 11th Human Rights Forum.
It has nothing to do with the genealogy of the disappearances that we are familiar with in the Southern Cone. In Mexico, it’s not about repressing, disappearing and torturing militants but something much more complex and terrible. A mother related the disappearance of her son, a communications engineer that was working for IBM, kidnapped by the narco to force him to construct a communications network at their service. “It can touch anyone,” she warns, saying that the whole society is within its sight and that, therefore, no one ought to remain at a distance.
Fundem was born in 2009, in Coahuila, and has achieved reuniting more than 120 families that look for 423 disappeared persons. It also works with the Truth and Justice Network, which looks for 300 Central American migrants disappeared in Mexican territory. “Collateral damage” former president Felipe Calderón called them, trying to minimize the tragedy of the disappearances. “They are beings that never had to have disappeared,” replies Contreras.
Worse than the Islamic State
A Fundem communiqué, for the purpose of the Third March of Dignity celebrated in May, emphasizes that “according to the Interior Ministry, as of February 2013, 26,121 persons were counted as disappeared,” since Calderón declared the “war against drug trafficking” in 2006. In May 2013, Christof Heyns, special relator on extrajudicial executions for the United Nations, said that the government recognized 102,696 homicides in the six-year term of Calderón (an average of 1,426 victims per month). But in last March, after 14 months of the current Peña Nieto government, the weekly Zeta counted 23,640 homicides (1,688 per month).
The information chain Al Jazeera published an analysis wherein it compares the deaths provoked by the Islamic State (IS) with the Mexican narco-massacres. In Irak, in 2014, the IS has ended the lives of 9,000 civilians, while the number of Mexican cartel victims in 2013 surpassed 16,000 (Russia Today, October 21 2014). The cartels carry out hundreds of decapitations every year. They have taken to dismembering and mutilating the victims’ bodies, to later expose them to intimidate the population. “For the same purpose, the cartels also attack women and children, and, just like the IS, publish graphic images of their crimes in the social networks.”
Many media outlets have been silenced through bribes or intimidations and since 2006 the cartels have been responsible for the murder of 57 journalists. The Islamic State murdered two US citizens, whose cases earned large media [attention], but few know that Mexican cartels murdered 293 US citizens between 2007 and 2010.
The question is not, nor should it be, who are the bloodiest, but rather why. Since we know that Al Qaeda and the Islamic State have been created by the United States intelligence services, it’s well worth asking question who is behind the drug trafficking.
Different studios and articles of investigative journalism emphasize the fusion between state authorities and narcos in Mexico. The magazine Proceso emphasizes in its latest edition that: “since the first trimester of 2013 the federal government was warned by a group of legislators, social activists and federal functionaries federales about the degree of penetration of organized crime into security areas of several Guerrero municipalities,” without obtaining the least response (Proceso, October 19, 2014).
Analyzing the links behind the recent massacre of the Ayotzinapa students (six dead and 43 disappeared), the journalist Luis Hernández Navarro concludes that the act “has uncovered the sewer of Guerreran narco-politics” (La Jornada, October 21, 2014). Members of all the parties participate in it, including the PRD, of the center left, to which José Luis Abarca, the municipal president of Iguala directly implied in the massacre belongs.
Raúl Vera was the Bishop of San Cristóbal de Las Casas when the hierarchy decided to separate Samuel Ruiz from that city. But Vera followed the same path of his predecessor and now exercises in Saltillo, the city in the state of Coahuila from where several mothers come that are members of Fundem. They don’t have their own place and they meet in the el Diocesan Human Rights Center. The Bishop and the mothers work elbow to elbow.
In 1996, Vera denounced the Acteal Massacre, where 45 indigenous Tzotziles were murdered while they were praying in a church in the community, in the state of Chiapas, among them 16 children and adolescents and 20 women. In spite of the fact that the massacre was perpetrated by paramilitaries opposed to the EZLN, the government attempted to present it as an ethnic conflict.
Controlling society
Because of his long experience, he maintains that the Ayotzinapa Massacre, “is a little message to the people, it is saying to us: see what we are capable of,” like happened in San Salvador Atenco in 2006, when members of the Peoples Front in Defense of Land, which participated in the Zapatistas’ Other Campaign, were brutally repressed with a result of two deaths, more than 200 detained, 26 of the women raped. The governor in charge of the injustice was Enrique Peña Nieto, the current president.
Those “messages” are repeated again and again in Mexican politics. The priest Alejandro Solalinde, who participated in the Forum on Human Rights, coordinates the Pacific South Pastorate on Human Mobility of the Mexican Episcopate and directs a shelter for migrants that pass through Mexico towards the United States, asserts that he received information that the students were burned alive. After being machine-gunned, the injured were burned, as police told him that they participated in the events and “longed for conscience” (Proceso, October 19, 2014).
If the style of murdering reveals a clear mafia message, the objectives ought to be discovered, to whom do they point and why. The answer comes from the hand of Bishop Vera. He emphasizes the intimate relationship between the cartels and the political, judicial and financial structures of the State, to the point that it is impossible to know where one begins and the other ends. To establish that reality leads him to assert that the leaders of his country “are organized crime” and that, therefore, “We are not in a democracy” (Proceso, October 12, 2014).
But the Bishop focuses his reflection towards a neuralgic point that permits untying the knot. “Organized crime has aided in the control of society and therefore it is an associate of the political class. They have attained that the people don’t organize, don’t grow.” Words more or less, but Subcomandante Marcos has pointed out the same thing.
Last, we’re not dealing with an accidental confluence but with a strategy. One of its constructors in the terrain is General Oscar Naranjo, who was one of the more outstanding “architects of the current Colombian narco-democracy” under the Álvaro Uribe government, as Carlos Fazio (La Jornada, June 30, 2012) would denounce. Naranjo, a DEA favorite and a “product of exportation” from the United States to the region, became an advisor of the Peña Nieto government.
Fazio emphasizes a Washington Post report where the newspaper asserts that: “seven thousand police and Mexican military members were trained by Colombian advisors.” It doesn’t take a great leap of the imagination to figure out where they began to manufacture the Mexican Failed State.
But there is more. “The United States government has helped some cartels through Operation Fast and Furious,” through which two thousand weapons were “involuntarily” placed in the hands of the narcos, the webpage antiwar.com reminds. It is possible, websites dedicated to strategic analysis reflect, like the European site dedefensa.org, that the Mexican chaos is favored by Washington’s growing paralysis and the cacophony that its diverse and contradictory services emit. Nevertheless, everything indicates that there is something deliberate. It should never be placed in doubt that it can boomerang across its extended and porous border.
From Puebla (Mexico)
– Raúl Zibechi is a Uruguayan journalist. He writes in Brecha and La Jornada and is an ALAI collaborator.
——————————————————
Originally Published in Spanish by ALAI, América Latina en Movimiento
Translation: Chiapas Support Committee
Tuesday, October 14, 2014
En español: http://alainet.org/active/78251
[Comment from an administrator of this blog: As you read this article, it would seem appropriate to remember that the U.S. government has urged and participated in Mexico’s so-called “Drug War” and financially supports Mexico’s Narco-State with beaucoup bucks while U.S. corporations make millions or billions off of selling the guns!]
GUERRERO AND NARCO-POLITICS
By: Luis Hernández Navarro
A narco-banner of two meters in length was found in the wee hours of October 16. It appeared in the rear fence of secondary school number 3 in Iguala, Guerrero, less than one kilometer from the 27th infantry battalion. On it, in a message written with letters printed in red and black paint, El Choky asks President Peña Nieto for justice. He denounces, with (first) names, last names and pseudonyms, those responsible for the murder and disappearance of the Ayotzinapa students.
The state’s attorney general, Iñaky Blanco, recently pointed to El Choky as chief of the Guerreros Unidos (Warriors United) gunmen, and the one responsible for ordering the massacre and disappearance of the youths last September 26, after the attack on them from police and gunmen.
The list of those associated with the criminal group and denounced in the banner is long: eight mayors, directors of Public Security, the Secretary of Agrarian, Territorial and Urban Development’s delegate and different personages. According to the denouncer, “they are the ones that the government lets walk around free and committing so much crime against the population.” Finally it clarifies: “I don’t have all the blame.” He signs: “Sincerely: Choky.”
The criminal climate denounced in the narco-message is not exclusive to Iguala and to seven municipal presidencies of Tierra Caliente. The kind of relationship between Mayor José Luis Abarca, his local police and organized crime, uncovered with the massacre of last September 26, is present in many Guerrero municipal governments. We’re dealing with a relationship that also involves important local politicians, state and federal legislators, party leaders, policía chiefs and military commanders. Thus, we are able to characterize the existing political regime in the state as a narco-state.
Denunciations like El Choky’s run from mouth to mouth among Guerrerans. Business leaders, social leaders and journalists have documented this nexus. Part of the local and national press has published it. In some cases, like in Iguala with the assassination of the Popular Union’s three leaders, formal accusations have even been presented to the relevant authorities. Everything has been in vain.
Those that have warned of the extent and depth of the narco-politics in the state have been eliminated and threatened. When the businessman Pioquinto Damián Huato, the leader of the Canaco in Chilpancigo, accused Mario Moreno, the city’s mayor, of having ties with the criminal group (called) Los Rojos, he was the victim of an attack in which his daughter-in-law died and his son was injured.
The politicians pointed to have invariably denied the accusations and have explained them as the result of political quarrels, or that they are not responsible for the behavior of their friends or relatives. They have said that the authorities ought to investigate them and that they are in the most willing to clarify things. But nothing g has been done. The pact of impunity that protects the political class has acted together time after time.
According to Bishop Raúl Vera, who was headed the Diocese of Ciudad Altamirano [1] between 1988 and 1995 impunity is the most lacerating characteristic of Guerrero and its most important challenge. Its extent and persistence –he points out– encourages crime and the violation of human rights and dignity.
But the violence is not only an issue of disputes between political-criminal groups for production centers, routes and plazas. It is also the result of the decision of the behind-the-scenes powers to get rid of opposition social leaders and to offer protection from (State) power to those that liquidate or disappear them.
The victims of forced disappearance and extrajudicial executions during the government of Ángel Aguirre are many. The correlation of murders and detained-disappeared during his administration is enormous.
Among many others, the ecologists Eva Alarcón Ortiz and Marcial Bautista Valle; the students Jorge Alexis Herrera and Gabriel Echeverría; the leaders of the Emiliano Zapata Revolutionary Agrarian League of the South, Raymundo Velázquez and Samuel Vargas; the environmentalist Juventina Villa and his son Reynaldo Santana; the Iguala council member, Justino Carbajal; members of the Popular Union Arturo Hernández, Rafael Banderas and Ángel Román; Rocío Mesino, who was the face of the Campesino Organization of the Southern Sierra; campesinos Juan Lucena and José Luis Sotelo, promoters of a self-defense group in Atoyac; the campesino organizers José Luis Olivares Enríquez and Ana Lilia Gatica Rómulo all make up part of it.
The narco-politics is not an issue exclusive to the old PRI. Members of various currents within the PRD have been pointed out as part of it. A member of the New Left [current] and president of the state Congress, Bernardo Ortega, has repeatedly been pointed to as boss of the Los Ardillos group. His father was in prison for the murder of two AFI agents del and was executed upon being released.
Servando Gómez, La Tuta, revealed in a video that Crescencio Reyes Torres, brother of Carlos, state leader of the Aztec Sun [meaning the PRD] and part of Grupo Guerrero [2], led by David Jimenez, is one of the principal “owners” of laboratories for the manufacture of synthetic drugs, allied with the Jalisco Nueva Generación Cartel.
At the same time, Governor Aguirre has repeatedly been linked with the Independiente de Acapulco Cartel. It is said that its leader, Víctor Aguirre, is the governor’s cousin. Of course, the governor as well as the rest of those accused have emphatically rejected and nexus with criminal groups.
Despite the multitude of denunciations against mayors and state officials, arrests have been scarce. Feliciano Álvarez Mesino, mayor of Cuetzala del Progreso, was arrested for kidnapping and organized. He was freed from blame as part of Grupo Guerrero. The official PRI mayor of Chilapa, Vicente Jiménez Aranda, was put in prison for kidnapping.
The murder and forced disappearance of the Ayotzinapa students has uncovered the sewer of Guerreran narco-politics. It remains to be seen whether they can put the lid back on.
[1] Ciudad Altamirano is a large city on the Guerrero side of the border with the state of Michoacán.
[2] Grupo Guerrero is a current, or faction, within the Party of the Democratic Revolution (PRD) in the state of Guerrero.
———————————————————–
Originally Published in Spanish by La Jornada
Translation: Chiapas Support Committee
Tuesday, October 21, 2014
En español: http://www.jornada.unam.mx/2014/10/21/opinion/021a2pol
JOINT DECLARATION OF THE NATIONAL INDIGENOUS CONGRESS AND THE EZLN ABOUT THE AYOTZINAPA CRIME AND FOR THE FREEDOM OF THE YAQUI LEADERS
(NOTE: CNI members read this text in some of the mobilizations that were held in Mexico on October 22, 2014, and not, as reported in the press for pay, by EZLN representatives)
Mexico, October 22, 2014
To students of the Isidro Burgos Rural Teachers College, Ayotzinapa, Guerrero
To the Yaqui Tribe
To the National and International Sixth
To the peoples of the world
BECAUSE IT IS WITH RAGE AND REBELLION, NOT WITH RESIGNATION AND CONFORMISM, HOW WE BELOW GRIEVE. EZLN. October 19, 2014
From the peoples that we are in our struggles of resistance and rebellion, we send our word as a mirror of that part of this country that we call the National Indigenous Congress, united because the pain and rage call to us because we grieve.
The disappearance of the 43 student compañeros of the Isidro Burgos Rural Teachers College of Ayotzinapa, Guerrero, kidnapped-disappeared by the Bad Governments, imposes a penumbra of mourning, anxiety and rage. Hope for the appearance of the compañeros is the pain that unites us and it is rage that becomes the light of the candle that mobilizes throughout the country bearing a cry of dignity and rebellion in the Mexico Below.
We know that while the criminals govern this country headed by the supreme chief of the paramilitaries, Enrique Peña Nieto, those that construct conscience by exercising and defending education are murdered and disappeared and those that defend the water for a heroic and millennial people like the Yaqui Tribe are in prison.
The Mexican government has sought to minimize the criminal repression towards the student compañeros as if they were more victims of crime, as they have done time and time again throughout the country. They may be just a few more deaths for the communications media, but we peoples that have suffered multiple forms of repression know that the criminals are in all the political parties, in the chambers of deputies and senators, in municipal presidencies, in government palaces.
Ayotzinapa pains us as native peoples. The 43 student compañeros remain disappeared and the State acts like it doesn’t know where they are, as if it had not been the State that took them away. They seek to disappear conscience and today the disappeared are present in this country’s thoughts, in the attentive gaze and the heart of those of us that are the National Indigenous Congress.
There are dangerous mafias in this country and they are called the Mexican State. We disturb them, we the peoples that struggle, we that have had no face and have had it torn away. We are nobody to them, we who see and feel the violence, we who suffer multiple and simultaneous attacks, we who know that something evil, very evil, is happening in this country in this country. It’s called war, and it is against all of us. It’s a war that we below see and suffer in its totality.
Today we reiterate that as long as our student compañeros of Ayotzinapa do not appear alive and in the state of Sonora our brothers Mario Luna Romero and Fernando Jiménez are in prison for defending the sacred water of the Yaqui River, as long as they remain kidnapped by the bad governments, we will continue responding accordingly.
The Narco State operates in the entire country, as in Guerrero, through repression against the peoples, extraction of natural resources and destruction of territories without scruples. It uses terrorism to manufacture pain and fear as its way of governing.
That pain and rage have been converted into dignity and rebellion against the war of extermination, because the opposite is waiting for death, dispossession and more pain and rage.
We demand the presentation with life of the 43 disappeared students and the dismantlement of the entire State structure that maintains organized crime!
We demand the immediate liberation of compañeros Mario Luna and Fernando Jiménez!
Your pain is ours! Your rage is ours!
October 22, 2014 Never More a Mexico without Us
National Indigenous Congress Indigenous Revolutionary Clandestine Committee-General Command of the Zapatista National Liberation Army
—————————————–
Originally Published in Spanish by Enlace Zapatista: http://enlacezapatista.ezln.org.mx/2014/10/23/declaracion-conjunta-cni-ezln-del-22-octubre-2014-nota-este-texto-fue-leido-por-miembros-del-cni-en-alguna-de-las-movilizaciones-que-se-realizaron-en-mexico-el-22-de-octubre-del-2014-y-no-como-re/